Get a Quote!

Make A Payment

For your convenience, we have listed below the phone numbers and payment mailing addresses for the companies we represent in alphabetical order. You may also choose to make your payments online. Payments can also be made at our office Monday through Friday between 9-5pm. As always, if you have any questions, please feel free to contact our office.

Note: If your policy is or may be in cancellation, an online payment will not automatically reinstate your policy. Call Dressel & Evans Agency Inc. at 614-488-9273 to discuss possible reinstatement of your policy.

  • Auto Owners Insurance Company

    Auto Owners Insurance Company

    Pay by Mail: Auto Owners Insurance Company
    2325 N. Cole St.
    Lima, OH 45801

  • Grange Insurance Company

    Grange Insurance Company

    Pay by Phone: 800.425.1100

    Pay by Mail: Grange Insurance Company
    P.O. Box 740604
    Cincinnati, OH 45274-0604

    Pay Online Click here »

  • The Motorists Insurance Group

    The Motorists Insurance Group

    Pay by Phone: 800.611.9928

    Pay by Mail: The Motorists Insurance Group
    PO Box 182155
    Columbus OH 43218

    Pay Online Click here »

  • Pekin Insurance

    Pekin Insurance

    Pay by Phone: 877.322.0160

    Pay by Mail: Pekin Insurance
    2505 Court Street
    Pekin, IL 61558-0001

    Pay Online Click here »

  • Progressive Insurance

    Progressive Insurance

    Pay by Phone: 800.925.2886

    Pay by Mail: Progressive Insurance
    PO Box 6807
    Cleveland, OH 44101-1807

    Pay Online Click here »

  • State Auto Insurance Company

    State Auto Insurance Company

    Pay by Mail: State Auto Insurance Company
    PO Box 182738
    Columbus, OH 43218